Condition monitoring specialist company, WearCheck, offers a wide range of analysis and testing techniques to boost the lifespan of industrial assets and to ensure that the assets perform at optimum levels.
In this article, technical manager for WearCheck, Steven Lara-Lee Lumley, discusses the merits of detergent additives in lubricants as part of a comprehensive condition monitoring programme.
Detergent additives
| What are they? | Organo-metallic compounds of calcium and magnesium phenolates, phosphates and sulphonates |
| What do they do? | Keep surfaces free of deposits and neutralise corrosive acids |
| How do they do it? | Chemical reaction with sludge and varnish precursors to neutralise them and keep them soluble |
Detergents play an important behind-the-scenes role in our everyday lives – they remove stains from our clothes, clean our floors, wash our hair and yes, they even keep our engines clean. Detergents are essentially cleansing agents which combine with impurities to make them more soluble in a given medium. And for those budding etymologists out there, the word detergent is derived from the Latin verb detergere, which means to wipe off or cleanse.
Detergents in lubricants are cleaning agents that contain metals. They are primarily used in engine oils and are mostly alkaline or basic in nature. They work in the high temperature combat zone of the engine (rings, pistons, liners and vales) to keep surfaces free of deposits, especially at ring grooves. They also neutralise harmful acids generated by the combustion of fuel, and provide rust protection.
The first engine oil detergents, (calcium carboxylate and phosphonate) were developed in the early 1940s and – by the 1950s – the engine oil market had exploded, with lubricants containing over-based sulphonates and salicylates. Interestingly enough, calcium sulphonates still make up about 60% of total detergent consumption when it comes to finished engine lubricants.
These cleaning agents are oil-soluble, organo-metallic compounds with polar heads, which allows them to cling to metal surfaces. Deposits and metal surfaces are both polar, and deposits are drawn to the metal surfaces and stick to them. The detergent additive, with its stronger charge, displaces these deposits from the metal surface.
Detergents have a similar structure to that of dispersant additives, with a polar head and a long, non-polar hydrophobic tail, but detergents contain a metal salt on an acidic organic molecule in their polar head.
Detergents and dispersants are the power couple of the engine oil additive world, and, as such, their relationship is synergistic in nature – while detergents remove deposits, they also work together with dispersants to keep these deposits in suspension in the oil by preventing the formation of large polar aggregates from settling on metal surfaces.
The additive treat rate of an engine oil is dependent on several factors, like the performance specification (e.g. API – American Petroleum Institute, JACO – Japanese Automotive Standards Organisation etc), the engine manufacturer’s approval, the type and viscosity of base oil, as well as the additive supplier, but – generally speaking – a fully formulated mineral engine oil would contain about 80% base oil, 8% VI (Viscosity Index) improver and round about 12% additive package. Of that 12%, detergent and dispersant additives make up between 55-70% so, it stands to reason that the chemistry of the total package and finished oil is greatly influenced by these two components and their interactions with each other.
Now for the nifty chemistry part – detergents are composed of two components, a surfactant and a colloidal inorganic phase. The combination of a surfactant molecule with a colloidal inorganic core results in a micellar-type structure.
This basic colloidal carbonate neutralises acids formed during the combustion process, such as nitric and sulfuric acid, which can lead to metal corrosion and wear, as well as organic acids, which can lead to polymerisation and oil thickening. The all-important Total Base Number (TBN) of the oil is an expression of this neutralisation ability.
The surfactant component of the detergent forms a protective layer on metal surfaces, resulting in the prevention of deposit build-up, rust and corrosion. The surfactant and the basic components work together to inhibit rust and corrosion, oil degradation, reduce high-temperature deposits and solubilise polar components.
One of the main driving forces behind new engine oil formulations is compatibility with exhaust aftertreatments systems, like DPFs (diesel particulate filters).
To protect these systems, new-generation engine oils must contain lower SAPS (Sulphated Ash, Phosphorus and Sulphur) levels since SAPS can poison, deactivate or block these emission-control after-treatment devices. Due to their metallic nature, detergents in conventional engine oils are prone to producing residues and ash when burned in the engine, which, unfortunately, contributes to the SAPS level of the oil and can cause DPFs to block.
The move towards low-SAPS engine oils will result in a shift from traditional engine oil technologies to alternative chemistries, with more focus on ashless, metal-free detergent additive systems.
Author bio:
Steven Lara-Lee Lumley is in charge of technical development and training for condition monitoring specialists WearCheck. She holds an N6 mechanical engineering diploma (HND N6) as well as Honeywell aerospace and ICML III accreditations.
Steven joined WearCheck in 2008 as a diagnostician and worked her way up to the position of senior diagnostician, during which time she diagnosed her millionth used oil sample in addition to running oil analysis training courses for customers in several countries. In 2015, Steven was promoted to the position of technical manager.
